Main
 
Judging Criteria

Evaluation of Content:

  • Is the information credible/informative?
  • Is the information complete? Is anything of significance to the user missing?
  • Is there a clear focus on the targeted health behavior(s)?
  • Is the information appropriate for the target audience?
  • Are any technical terms/concepts clearly explained? Does the content minimize any confusion about the subject?
  • Is the information new and/or relevant to the user? Is there any indication that the information is regularly updated?
  • Is the site's sponsor clearly identified? Are there e-mail links and/or feedback forms to allow for user interaction?

Evaluation of Creative Format:

  • Assess the site's overall design and layout. Is the design appropriate for the target audience?
  • Is the site layout and navigation user-friendly? Are links easily identifiable?
  • Does the site maintain a consistent personality through the use of design?
  • Are visuals/graphics relevant to the subject matter? Is there effective use of color? (For advertising/marketing health pages only — are banner ads (if any) — appropriate for the site design?)
  • Does the site make use of newer web technologies (e.g., Flash, Java, Dynamic HTML, ASP, XML, etc.) to further enhance the user experience?
  • Is the health information message(s) clear and consistent? Are the main points stressed and repeated?

Overall Assessment:

  • Information quality and depth
  • Site design and structure
  • Relevant health information for the target audience
  • Ease of navigation
  • Ability to attract and hold users' interests
  • Significance to overall public health interests (for non-commercial and/or non-professional sites)
  • Overall site use of the web's interactive nature — not simply an electronic version of a brochure or newsletter, etc.
  • Special consideration for commercial health sites: ability to elicit appropriate action?
EVALUATION
SCORE
EXCELLENT TO OUTSTANDING
81-100
ABOVE AVERAGE
61-80
AVERAGE
41-60
FAIR
21-40
POOR
0-20
 

Previous
Winners

Adobe® Acrobat® Reader Required
 
Sponsors:
Association of Marketing & Sales Executives in Senior Housing
 
 
American Custom Publishing Corporation
 
Call for Judges
Interested in serving as a judge for the World Wide Web Health Awards?
Click here

Main | Details | Entry Form | Winning Sites | Call for Judges
National Mature Media Awards | About the MMRC